Pick A Bagel

891 8th Ave, New York

●7.3 · Closed

🥯 Bagels5 reviews5 savesUpdated 2/17/26

Reviews for you

MayaFeb 17

891 8th Ave

●10.0

my best bagel spot

maddyNov 15

891 8th Ave

●8.8

JennNov 6

891 8th Ave

●5.9

891 8th Ave

●4.0

Bagel shop in Hell's Kitchen. Bagels were ok - didn't feel super fresh tbh, and the cream cheese shmear was a tad much...

shivamAug 16

891 8th Ave

●7.8