Fire cookie but #1 in nyc seems crazy. I feel like now I must try more and report back. Was a thin cookie which I love. Also, I’m sad I thought “oh wow it’s only $4.50” 😪. @nikhil might be worth adding to the list of ones to check!
According to Infatuation this is NYC’s #1 chocolate chip cookie and honestly it was sooo good! the toffeee and the salt was a perfect mix :’) Idk about number 1 but would def say top 5 cookies in New York??
