Bumnas's review of Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria
Neptune City, New Jersey
JasonApr 10
●8.8
Lists with Pete & Elda's Bar / Carmen's Pizzeria
I like the pizza. Some people say the crust has no flavor but personally I like how thin and crunchy it is. Comparing this to doughy pizzas, I prefer it because you could load it up with good topics and not have dough take up space. 9/10 pizza for me!
The experience: We decided to do the challenger where you finish an XXL pie in less than 30 minutes for their limited edition monthly tees. We tortured ourselves and decided to race to finish. It was a terrible experience. Obviously I won and finished the pie in 15 minutes. It got real nasty after slice #6. If done at a normal speed it would’ve been alright 😭
The waitress was super nice too. When we got the shirts (easter/bugs bunny themed), they only cane in XL size. Def coming back to try the other menu options!
