Liberty Bagels 5th Ave

Liberty Bagels 5th Ave

16 E 58th St, New York

●7.8 · $9.50 · Open

🍳 Breakfast🥯 Bagels28 photos18 reviews4 savesUpdated 6/1/26

TikTok & Reels

External content

External content

Reviews for you

graceJun 1

Midtown East, Manhattan

●8.3

Goose Day: Liberty Bagels (5th Ave.)! Got the Birthday Bagel with Birthday Cream Cheese hehehehehhe - IDK why everyone poops on this Bagel, it's not that bad, I think LB probs just assumes so many people will want this bagel, so they prep like so many more of these than the other ones so it just becomes slightly harder than the others more quickly 😭 Overall was yummy, yippee Goose Day brekkie! Side note: It was SO busy when I went to this location (around 9:45am). $7.46 turned into $0 😎😎😎 Frick Yeah :P

Review media

Review media

Review media

Review media

Review media

Review media

Review media

Review media

NunuApr 25

Midtown East, Manhattan

●10.0

Review media

Review media

kaylaApr 1

Midtown East, Manhattan

●5.0

remembering how bad this rainbow bagel was😔😦💔🫩🥲

Review media

Review media

Review media

Review media

ChloëMar 26

Midtown East, Manhattan

●8.6

Nothing better than a NEW YORK bagel

Review media

Review media

RubeeMar 8

Midtown East, Manhattan

●7.0

The blueberry cream cheese was heavenly! My rainbow bagel was squashed so not very aesthetic but still cute. Decent bagel

Review media

SethtcowperFeb 4

Midtown East, Manhattan

●7.5

Not the biggest rainbow bagel fan lol but their other options are amazing ! I’m surprised the hype isn’t more focused on what else they offer

Review media

Midtown East, Manhattan

●8.4

Got some to share with some fam we visited before going to the airport!

Review media

SophieDec 31

Midtown East, Manhattan

●8.4

Always so good! After having PopUp bagels, liberty is def more dense and heavy but both r great in their own ways. Alex liked popup more and mom likes liberty more soooo

Review media

AdoniaNov 17

Midtown East, Manhattan

●10.0

Review media

SophieAug 28

Midtown East, Manhattan

●6.7

Came back for seconds before leaving town! They didn’t have their Asiago cheese bagel so I got a garlic bagel instead and they gave us a free everything bagel too! I like the Asiago cheese bagel better than the garlic bagel but still v good!

Review media

Review media

SophieAug 23

Midtown East, Manhattan

●9.5

First stop in nyc! Went for more savory options this morning and my chicken sandwich was soooo goodddd! Alex said the bacon egg and cheese was “good” and moms sesame bagel was “delicious” 😁

Review media

Review media

SophieJun 24

Midtown East, Manhattan

●8.4

A must when visiting nyc 🤍 always delectable and we always go without fail when we’re in town

Review media

Review media

Review media

LivApr 4

Midtown East, Manhattan

●9.6

AnikaMar 13

Midtown East, Manhattan

●5.7

Midtown East, Manhattan

●7.8

AniDec 5

Midtown East, Manhattan

●4.1

sammyDec 4

Midtown East, Manhattan

●10.0

LilyNov 9

Midtown East, Manhattan

●4.6